REAL STORIES
BY REAL PEOPLE Search
Monday, December 11, 2017

Increase in the number of IVF clinics in India.

by Robert Simms (writer), , August 22, 2010

Credit: Barcroft India/Barcroft Medi
Rajo Devi Lohan became a mother at age 70.

In vitro fertilization clinics are now the latest craze, particularly for women 60 years old and older.

This is so wrong on oh, so many levels; it's difficult to know just where to begin.

In India, home of 1.2 billion souls, in vitro fertilization clinics are now the latest craze, particularly for women 60 years old and older.

India does not, apparently, place many - if any - restrictions on it's 550 registered in vitro fertilization clinics; it seems like anything goes. According to a Washington Post article, in the National Fertility Center in Hisar,Haryana India only 60% of the women impregnated at the clinic carried their pregnancies to full term.

The article goes on to say that the clients fall into two categories; one group of older women who wish to eliminate the "stigma" associated with infertility and a second group of career minded couples who choose to wait until their careers were established before having children. Both groups are inherently selfish; choosing their own desires over what might be best for the child.

Reading the Washington Post article, one can begin to appreciate the Catholic Church's policy concerning What’s Wrong With In-Vitro Fertilization:

Father Tadeusz PachoIczyk, director of education at the National Catholic Bioethics Center in Philadelphia, explained that the Church teaches that the procedure is immoral for several reasons. "It undermines the meaning of sex. It violates the exclusivity of the couple's marriage covenant," Father Pacholczyk said. "It says that it is okay to manufacture life in a laboratory as if it were a commodity, when it should be the result of human love."

"There's also the ancillary evil of freezing embryonic humans that are later abandoned or poured down the sink if they are not useful," he added. In addition, Father Pacholczyk noted that babies created through in-vitro fertilization have an elevated risk of birth defects. "Studies have shown a six fold elevated risk for in-vitro fertilization children contracting an eye disease called retinal blastoma versus normally conceived babies," he said. "In-vitro fertilization is very unnatural. You're extracting ova from the woman, culturing them and inspecting the developing embryo in a laboratory setting. They are in a completely unnatural environment for a very long time before they are put back into the womb.


Further research into the Church's stance on the immorality of in vitro lead me to a story from 2006 [Good News, You're Pregnant - Bad News, You're Fired. and Catholic School Teacher Fired for Having In Vitro].
Like far too many Catholics, Kelly and Eric Romenesko knew very little about the Church's teachings in this area. Kelly, who was a French teacher at a Catholic school, was fired after informing her supervisors that she had become pregnant via in vitro. Since the church forbids IVF, she had violated school rules requiring teachers to live according to Catholic doctrine.

Kelly Romenesko reportedly said,

"I did not know what the Catholic doctrine stated against in vitro fertilization. Yes, I signed a contract, but the contract was vague in my opinion. I didn't know what I was doing as far as in vitro goes that that went against doctrine. My understanding was it was the Ten Commandments."

According to one article,

"When Romenesko asked for time off for fertility treatments, her boss at Xavier High School, where she was hired in 2002, referred her to a priest who laid out the church's problems with IVF. She says she left the meeting with the sense that 'this is against church teaching, but I am a good person and will be accepted by the church.' She and Eric are still considering what to do with the frozen embryos left over from their IVF."

Being someone who believes the Roman Catholic Church should follow his teachings, Eric Romenesko said,

"I think the issue here is the fact that Kelly was released from her job for being pregnant, not the in vitro fertilization itself," Eric said. "Our daughters have been baptized Lutheran at this point in time. Kelly and I haven't converted yet."

Mr. Romenesko is, of course, a bozo. The Church encourages Catholics to have children and according to her own statement, his wife had the sense that 'this is against church teaching'.



About the Writer

Robert Simms is a writer for BrooWaha. For more information, visit the writer's website.
Want to write articles too? Sign up & become a writer!

2 comments on Increase in the number of IVF clinics in India.

Log In To Vote   Score: 1
By Barkha Dhar on August 22, 2010 at 09:12 pm

This is something that appears to be unethical. There should be a law that restricts such practice for couples who are in dire need of a child. Also there needs to be an age limit because birthing is not just about anatomy but primarily about parenting. What happens to a child who is bron to an elderly mother who is possibly counting days of her life. Probably the child would end up in foster care. By doing this we seem to be playing foul with nature and nurture.

Thanks for sharing this news

Barkha Dhar

 Report abuse

Log In To Vote   Score: 0
By Arcticulates on August 25, 2010 at 11:09 am

In vitro fertilization has helped many women become a mom who normally wouldn't have had a chance. Maybe there should be a age limit, but first maybe we need to set that limit on how old the man is who can provide the sperm... They are and should be just as responsible in the 18 years or more of parenting as the woman who carries the pregnancy to full term. I know some very spry and active women in their 90's who are somewhat healthier then I am.. on the other hand if worrying about someone dying before the child grows up.... Nobody is promised tomorrow!

 Report abuse



Add A Comment!

Click here to signup or login.


Rate This Article


Your vote matters to us



x


x