Joel and Ethan Coen are masters at what they do; making entertaining movies that have a lot more going on than you see the first time. They've made some of my favorite films such as "Raising Arizona","Blood Simple" "O Brother Where Art Thou?", and the magnificent "Miller's Crossing", which is one of the best gangster movies ever made. If you haven't seen any of their movies, you need to rectify that error the next time you wonder what to rent for a Friday or Saturday night.
BARTON FINK was written when the Brothers Coen claimed they suffered writer's block while they were working on the screenplay for "Miller's Crossing" and all I can say is this: if this is the kind of story they came up with when they were blocked, they oughta get blocked more often since they won all sorts of awards at Cannes for BARTON FINK and movie critics raved about it and it was on everybody's lists of the best movies released during that year.
Barton Fink (John Turturro) is a New York playwright who is enjoying success on Broadway with his latest play in the year 1941. His agent gets him a sweet deal to go out to California and work in Hollywood. Capital Studios is offering Barton $2,000 a week to come out there and write movies. And back in those days, $2,000 a week was a fortune. Barton doesn't want to go but his agent wisely advises him that if he takes the deal, he can put food on his table and keep a roof over his head while Barton writes the stuff he really wants to write. Barton finally accepts and goes out to Hollywood where he takes a room in The Hotel Earle, a really odd establishment that seems to have only two employees; a decrepit elevator operator who appeared to be nearly ossified and the cheerful desk clerk Chet (Steve Buscemi)
Barton immediately catches writer's block since he's never written a movie script before. Hell, he doesn'™t even go to movies and his first assignment is to script a wrestling movie starring Wallace Beery. Barton seeks help from a variety of characters such as the alcoholic writer W.P. Mayhew (John Mahoney) and producer Ben Geisler (Tony Shaloub)
Part of Barton's problem is that while he loudly proclaims to anybody who will listen that he wants to write about "The Common Man" he truly doesn't know anything about his subject. As the story goes on we see that his intellect actually gets in the way of his empathy and distorts his emotional life. This is pointed out in a series of really funny scenes with the producer Ben Geisler who at one point replies to Barton's dilemma with exasperation:"Jesus, Fink! What do you need to know? It's a wrestling picture! It's not fucking Hamlet!"
Geisler has a terrific scene where he takes Barton to lunch and advises him to talk to another writer and Barton asks where does he find a writer in Hollywood. Geisler replies with one of my Top Ten Favorite Lines Of All Time; "This town is loaded with 'em; throw a rock and you'll hit one. And do me a favor, Fink - when you throw that rock be sure and throw it hard."
Geisler is played by Tony Shaloub who has a show on USA called 'Monk' and if you haven't watched it yet, you really oughta to as it's a terrific show and amply demonstrates the amazing range of Tony Shaloub. You watch him in this movie and in 'Monk' and it's impossible for me to imagine that it's the same actor playing these characters.
Barton has a next-door neighbor in the Hotel Earle, an insurance salesman named Charlie Meadows (John Goodman) who tries to help Barton out with his writer's block. Hell, Charlie figures that you can't get more common man than him, but he soon finds that Barton is more interested in ranting about his own theories on what the common man wants than actually finding out what the common man thinks. The theme of Barton's ignorance about what he thinks writing is supposed to be about runs through the entire movie and is handled in some very funny scenes. There's one in which Barton having a picnic with Mayhew and his secretary (Judy Davis) and Barton is spouting his intellectual bullshit about writing and how it's this divine calling and he cannot separate himself from his art. Mayhew gives him this really pitying look and says; "Hell, I just like making things up."
But BARTON FINK isn't just about a writer's trials and tribulations in Hollywood. It's also about a grisly, horrifying murder and a frightening revelation concerning the jovial, amiable Charlie Meadows that just may have infernal origins. If you've seen BARTON FINK then you know exactly what I'm talking about and I wouldn't dream of spoiling it for those of you who haven't. But at the same time BARTON FINK is also a very funny movie and sometimes you don't know if you should be laughing or not. And indeed, there are scenes where Barton himself doesn't know if he should be taking the people he's talking to seriously or not, including two police detectives who appear to take a perverse delight in the way they verbally ping-pong their interrogation of Barton back and forth like Abbott and Costello doing "Who's On First?"
One of the fun things about this movie is that there's always something new I see every time I view it (which is about once a year) and I delight in the performances of John Turturro (he'™s been in a number of Spike Lee films) John Goodman, Judy Davis and John Mahoney (who delivers the funniest rendition of "Old Black Joe" I've ever heard) as well as the way the story is told. Jon Polito is also on hand playing the virtual slave of a fierce studio boss (Michael Lerner) And if anybody can figure out just what the final scene of the movie is about, email me and give a brother a clue, wouldja?