Friday, July 20, 2018

"Happiness" is not for Indians yet

by Proloy Bagchi (writer), Idgah Hills, Bhopal, May 07, 2015

Deeply involved as the Indian Administration is in lifting the huge population from poverty and malnutrition, it cannot pay attention to their finer things of life "Happiness"

In the World Happiness Report of 2015 of the United Nations on 158 countries India has slipped from 111th place in 2013 to 117th. This, obviously, means that people in India have become unhappier during the last two years. The report covers the period from 2012 to 2014 and takes into account not just individual satisfaction and wealth but also broad contentment that includes social support, high healthy life expectancy, freedom to make life choices, perceptions of corruption, pro-sociality – the kind of conduct that may include honesty, benevolence, cooperation and trustworthiness. With Switzerland expectedly topping the list, Nordic countries make up the top five. South Asia generally is in the bottom half and what is perhaps a reason for concern is that India has been ranked below Pakistan and Bangladesh – two countries that of late have been facing Islamic terror and yet their happiness quotient has come out to be higher. Bhutan, which practices the concept of Gross National Happiness and inspired the study through the UN General Assembly, has been ranked 79th – higher than India, yet a not-too-high a rank, given the head start it had in reckoning “happiness” (as against “product”) as a metric for growth and development.

According to the Summary of the 2015 report, the world has come a long way since the first report was launched in 2012. It asserts, “Increasingly happiness is considered a proper measure of social progress and goal of public policy. A rapidly increasing number of national and local governments are using happiness data and research in their search for policies that could enable people to live better lives”. We in India, however, are not aware of any move to collect “Happiness” data at city, state or country levels to enable the administration to frame policies to mitigate the general feelings of unhappiness and misery. If at all this has been done, apparently, the official organisations responsible for collection of such data have been doing so in a surreptitious manner. Not a word seemed to have been breathed to the media.

That, of course, is another story and not material to this piece. What, however, needs to be pointed out is that over the last three or four years the method of measurement of “Happiness” has been refined. The 2012 report was based basically on the assessment of “Happiness”, whereas the succeeding reports have, in addition, assessed the feelings of “Wellbeing” among those who were surveyed. “Wellbeing” is being measured in the United Kingdom and OECD countries and perhaps measurement of “wellbeing”, especially “subjective wellbeing”, will be true reflection of people’s quality of life – as against the “gross domestic product”. We know how during the years of high growth rates in the country’s GDP quality of life of vast numbers of people did not improve in any way. Poverty, mal and under-nourishment, high infant and maternal mortality rates have continued to haunt the nation.

The report has been produced on the basis of some data that are already available with a few international organisations and others were made available by Gallop World Poll (GWP) against eight constructs, viz. (1) “GDP per capita” in terms of Purchasing Power Parity taken from World Development Indicators released by World Bank in 2014, (2) “Social Support“ available for individuals is the national average of binary responses (of either 0 or 1) to GWP question, (3) data on “Healthy life expectancy” has again been borrowed from World Health Organisation and World Development Indicators (4) “Freedom to make life choices” is again a national average of binary responses to the GWP question “Are you satisfied or dissatisfied with your freedom to choose what you do with your life”, (5) “Generosity” is the national average of the responses to the GWP question “whether you donated money in the past month”, (6) “Perceptions of corruption” are again national average of binary responses to GWP poll to the question “whether corruption was widespread in the government and also within business” (7) “Positive affect” is defined as previous day’s affect measures of happiness, laughter and enjoyment” and (8) “Negative affect” is defined as the average of previous-day affect measures for worry, sadness and anger.

As of the eight above, GDP per capita in terms of Purchasing Power Parity and figures on “Healthy Life Expectancy” have been taken from relevant international organisations there is some kind of finality about them since these are based on national data fed to them. Predictably, per capita GDP and healthy life expectancy are depressed and have apparently pulled the country down a few notches. The life expectancy was stated in January 2014 to have risen in cases of both the genders. But “Healthy life expectancy” is quite another matter – given the state of environment, sanitation and healthcare in the country. A google search failed to reveal India’s “Healthy Life Expectancy”.

Brief comments on each of the six constructs are as follows: Prevalence of “social support” is generally insignificant. It is the lucky few who are able to network and can expect support in times of physical or emotional distress. But indifference of general public to distressed fellow humans is graphically exemplified by accident victims or molested females in public spaces in the country who are left to deal with their misfortunes themselves. Any kind of “Social Support” cannot be taken as a given in India like in more developed countries. Similarly, the freedom to make “Life Choices” of a largely poor, illiterate/semi-literate and unskilled population residing in a country bereft of job opportunities has got to be restricted. And, if one does not have enough to live a dignified life how can he be expected to show “Generosity” by making donations? “Public and Business Corruption” cases have, of late, caught the attention of everyone. Almost every day new cases of fraud of mindboggling amounts are revealed. When huge amounts of public money find their way into private pockets the probability of “Happiness” of vast numbers of people would necessarily recede. Besides, in rural or urban life “Negative Affects” top the “Positives”. Barring a few financially well off, the masses, by and large, get back home harried and distressed after their daily struggle.

Though inspired by Bhutan which is trying to shun consumerism, the report is basically meant for economically advanced countries which, after becoming prosperous, are now trying to take the lives of their citizens to a higher level of contentment and emotional wellbeing. Several countries reportedly are increasingly making use of the World Happiness Reports to fill the gaps in their respective systems to better the quality of life of their peoples. Economic wellbeing enables them to study the problems, if any, and change gears, if needed, to provide for a more fulfilling life of their citizens. Admittedly, material prosperity alone can neither be the sole objective of socio-economic development nor can it give people a sense of “Happiness” and “Wellbeing”.

However, in a highly populous country like India with illiterate/semiliterate or unskilled population that is generally engrossed in somehow making a living, such reports have, at best, only academic value. For such countries, measuring “Happiness” of the people is, therefore, a peripheral issue that can be put off for some other time, overwhelmed as the Indian and state governments are currently with the job of taking succor to the country’s hungry and undernourished millions. Hence, nothing would, surely, be done on the basis of this report in India just as no action was, apparently, taken on the 2012 and 2013 reports. Placement of the country at 117th position, therefore, seems very charitable. “Happiness” and “Wellbeing” of Indian masses do not yet figure in the lexicon of Indian administration.

About the Writer

Pushing 80 I was born in Gwalior in Central India to parents who were educated in Calcutta, now Kolkata. My father did his master's in English in 1916. He was a professor of English in the then only college in Gwalior. After qualifying in the exams for entry in to central civil services I served the government of India for 34 years reaching the very top of the professional cadres of the Indian Postal Service. I also acted as consultant ion behalf of the Universal Postal Union in Afghanistan, Ethiopia, Kenya, Tanzania and Swaziland.
Want to write articles too? Sign up & become a writer!

1 comments on "Happiness" is not for Indians yet

Log In To Vote   Score: 0
By zyt123 on October 29, 2015 at 04:47 am

Wang tommy hilfiger Anliang prada Piandian chanel out of moncler outlet the hilfiger online shop study, chanel outlet and longchamp bags immediately lululemon australia online shopping came hollister canada up several replica rolex guards. moncler This timberland work boots is louis vuitton handbags to true religion jeans women be tiffany outlet a woolrich outlet online routine cheap basketball shoes check, mizuno running shoes he giuseppe shoes will polo ralph lauren outlet online hand louis vuitton canada aloft, pounding michael kors outlet online heart, easton bats but polo ralph lauren nervous, nike factory store very gucci sneakers strict search hermes handbags to mac cosmetics outlet be abercrombie and fitch each michael kors search beats by dre headphones again by yoga pants different nike air huarache people, north face jackets clearance clothes, burberry handbags shoes air jordan shoes and cheap eyeglasses online socks, barbour jackets in advance, the rolex watches for sale mouth michael kors outlet should jimmy choo outlet be shoes outlet open dresses for wedding check, jordan retro 3 which bebe dresses is swarovski crystals wholesale the supra footwear court's michael kors outlet store rules, nike air is nike store to tommy hilfiger prevent cheap michael kors handbags the mercurial vapor eunuch oakley sunglasses outlet stealing new balance elsewhere, lululemon outlet while the air max study burberry sale is christian louboutin to ray ban sunglasses prevent montblanc confidential air max leaks, michael kors uhren ladies, hermes bags too. mac makeup Search by nike roshe run the air max old abercrombie ladies, but also tiffany canada to check beats by dre headphones the nike free place jumping.

Since they are hollister online shop deutschland to ralph lauren polo follow air force the nike running shoes old pandora bracelet eunuch custom roshe runs Wang Anliang cheap toms Prince, and oakley I michael kors never north face had abercrombie fitch any asics problems, so toms outlet some air jordan shoes inconvenient things hollister co free, but bride dresses ??? is nike shoe drilled this ray bans security loophole.

"Well, it!"

Bodyguard ray ban long burberry handbags straight harrods london bang command, Wang insanity workout schedule Anliang michael kors outlet online a cheap michael kors handbags long new balance sigh swarovski online shop of relief, burberry a nike free run heart toms shoes sale down, ralph lauren factory store he oakley sunglasses put on adidas shoes burberry factory outlet and hurried bags outlet out the rayban side jordan retro 11 hall.

Afternoon, horloges Wang prada purses Anliang michael kors outlet improper converse value, pandora bracelets he kate spade sale found an louboutin uk excuse coach outlet online to leave then louis vuitton outlet stores leave nike roshes the polo ralph lauren outlet Orient House.

Chang'an north face outlet City stroll watches for men in michael kors a large louis vuitton purses circle, uhren shop Wangan Liang coach outlet store online Qing palace finally appeared polo ralph lauren in the rayban back door, he north face heard oakley the ghd porter hermes bags informed, will soon michael kors outlet online sale be ralph lauren polo shirts ushered prada into the iphone 5s cases Qing burberry Wang's p90x study.

Study, tommy hilfiger canada Li nike Qiu hollister carefully to kate spade handbags a the north face outlet piece converse all star of gucci sneakers torn letters set coach outlet online on christian louboutin outlet a nike soccer shoes white sheet michael kors australia of paper, and soon nike an discount true religion jeans entire rolex replica letter will appear gucci shoes in front babyliss pro nano titanium of ugg boots australia their puma online shop son.

Li coach outlet Cong salvatore ferragamo repeatedly nike roche run read ray ban sunglasses outlet twice, gucci he tory burch handbags soon swarovski outlet found free runs a oakley sunglasses outlet key abercrombie and fitch point of cheap michael kors handbags this jerseys from china letter, true religion clearance but he was ray ban sunglasses outlet a lululemon canada little nike air max disappointed oakley sunglasses that the letter of coach bags mass destruction is swarovski australia not great, coach outlet store although gucci uk Li nike air max 2015 Heng hilfiger outlet slip of michael kors the michael kors tongue, louis vuitton but p90x3 schedule he also realized, oakley outlet store and adidas He christian louboutin outlet tore air jordan release up tommy hilfiger outlet stores online the burberry factory outlet letter, which pandora charms shows kate spade sale that ugg boots he mcm bag has realized pandora his oakley store mistake and pandora sale immediately corrected, nike air max 90 so north face jackets long ugg boots on sale as he tiffany's jewelry explained nike air max a louboutin shoes on sale little abercrombie and fitch to beats by dre headphones the thomas sabo charms Fu coach outlet online Huang, chanel bag the omega problem hogan is solved.

He has louboutin outlet been wanted reebok an burberry sale Hyung Lee oakley sunglasses outlet and sent troops pandora charms to the gateway new balance shoes command louis vuitton bags in tiffany the class, adidas shoes that beats by dre headphones may have joe's new balance outlet toppled tommy hilfiger outlet stores Hyung, ray ban but swarovski uk official site now. designer knockoff handbags . calvin klein outlet . thomas sabo . tory burch handbags Li Cong hollister co face oakley sunglasses outlet the coach factory outlet store color uggs canada of ugg australia disappointment.

??? mind tiffany and co australia uneasy louis vuitton australia next cheap nfl jerseys six months bcbg max azria ago, ralph lauren online Li michael kors Cong vans find him, mcm belt he promised sunglasses for women to levis outlet store Houshang, jerseys from china ordered designer purses him michael kors to come adidas online up with gucci sneakers Prince's jordan secret louboutin shoes letter gucci shoes which hollisterco is michael kors outlet important or unimportant. ray ban sunglasses outlet But he uggs is nike outlet very bcbg max smart, wrote cheap ray ban a letter today louis vuitton uk to youth baseball bats see the cheap clothes Prince abercrombie and fitch and tear, burberry outlet store they guessed uggs outlet letter coach outlet may huarache be useful adidas to uggs clearance this louis vuitton outlet waste, nike it louis vuitton black friday is nike outlet risky michael kors outlet to air max 95 steal ugg australia it cheap jordans for sale out, bottega veneta outlet but ralph lauren online shop to tory burch sandals celebrate the king's face, but ferragamo outlet does swarovski jewelry not ralph lauren outlet seem ralph lauren sale very happy.

Then michael kors factory outlet Li nike Qiu ugg outlet laughed: vans shoes outlet "Father, ugg boots on sale this long champ letter the north face outlet is longchamp very nike outlet useful, ugg we rolex replica watches need oakley outlet to christian louboutin shoes Wang adidas Gonggong roshe runs rewarded."

Li tom shoes Cong michael kors froze for michael kors handbags clearance a vans moment, true religion jeans outlet to north face canada steal cheap jordans out barbour sale of this letter, what gucci shoes a good prada purses reward, polo ralph lauren outlet but tory burch handbags he saw his ed hardy clothing son polo ralph lauren outlet online face marc by marc jacobs serious, fake rolex he michael kors outlet online nodded longchamp handbags and longchamp outlet said: chi hair "! salomon Wang chanel purses child, celine handbags this louis vuitton outlet online reward ray ban sunglasses outlet to nike you north face outlet to ferragamo outlet decide."

nike roshe run

 Report abuse

Add A Comment!

Click here to signup or login.

Rate This Article

Your vote matters to us