Thursday, July 19, 2018

The Heart of Horror

by Anastasia (writer), London, July 10, 2011

Credit: findmao2
Chinese Propaganda Poster from the 1950s

Let me take you on a great leap into the heart of one of the most awful events in Chinese history

Have you ever read Joseph Conrad’s novella Heart of Darkness? If you have you will recall the final words of Kurtz in his moment of epiphany shortly before his death - The horror! The horror!

Let me take you to another heart of darkness; let me take you to China in the middle of the twentieth century, to the time of the so-called Great Leap Forward. Last year I read Mao’s Great Famine by Frank Dikötter, a study of that grim period in the country’s history which has now deservedly been awarded the 2011 Samuel Johnson Prize for non-fiction, one of Britain’s most prestigious literary accolades.

It’s a sober, scholarly, thoroughly researched piece of work, written in clam and measured prose. But you should see my copy, see my marginalia, see the things I’ve written as I went along. I’ve not quite written The horror! The horror! though I came close, alighting on passages like this;

If the thatch on the roofs had not been consumed by fire, it was taken down and eaten in desperation. Villagers also ate the plaster from the walls. (p.169)

The worst form of desecration was to chop up the body and use it as fertiliser. This happened to Deng Daming, beaten to death because his child had stolen a few broad beans. Party Secretary Dan Naming ordered his body to be simmered down into fertiliser for a field of pumpkin. (p. 297)

Human flesh, like everything else, was traded on the black market. (p. 321)

But as desperate survivors all of them would have witnessed many of the horrors being inflicted on living human beings, from body parts being chopped off to people being buried alive. Surely, in the midst of state-sponsored violence, necrophagy was neither the most common nor the most widespread way of degrading a human being. (p. 323)

And so it goes on, the story of the most devastating manmade famine in all of history, one that is now estimated to have taken the lives of at least 45 million people.

I do have one small criticism of this book – the title is rather misleading. Yes, most people caught up in this madness died of hunger, but a great many died of disease or neglect or were worked to death, including pregnant women; others were beaten to death with clubs. Some two million in desperation took their own lives. And of course, going on the Marxist principle that those who do not work do not eat, the sick and the elderly were simply given no food at all.

The madness had a face: the face was Mao Zedong, one of the most abhorrent criminals in human history. It was his ‘vision’ that in a few years China could overtake the capitalist West and the Soviet Union in its rate of industrial development. It could all be done, he believed, by a single act of collective will, voluntarism, his particular contribution to Marxist thought. Opposition was dismissed as ‘rightist’, the work of ‘bad elements.’

The demand was for higher and higher targets in every field of economic activity; and since the whole system was driven by fear, higher and higher targets meant bigger and bigger lies; bigger and bigger lies meant more and more requisitions until people were left with a hundred per cent of nothing.

Farmers were driven from the fields to work on irrigation projects, worthless in the main, so no seeds were planted and crops grown. And since in the communist scheme of things steel production was an important sign of ‘getting it up’, Mao called for backyard furnaces into which people were compelled to throw all of their metal implements, even their cooking utensils, to receive brittle and worthless chunks of pig iron at the end. No matter, there was nothing to eat, so who needs a wok?

Existence was collectivised: people were driven into mass farms and then into vast communes. There was no defence in law, no right to private property; even nappies (diapers) were commandeered. But on it went, Mao urged forward by a sycophantic court. Sparrows, he decreed, were vermin, eating grain; sparrows were to be exterminated. They were, in their tens of thousands, with the result that the pests which made up the largest part of their diet multiplied out of control, with an even greater impact on the diminishing food supply. In the end, in one of the craziest trade deals in history, China was obliged to import sparrows from the Soviet Union.

I do not envy modern China its prosperity; how it has earned it by forms of suffering that most of us simply can’t conceive; the suffering of parents who sold their children, or relatives who had to dig up their dead in a country with a deep reverence for departed spirits simply because they had nothing else to eat.

It used to be said that when an imperial dynasty was coming to an end in the great cycles of Chinese history that it had lost the mandate of heaven. For a good part of the twentieth century, from the Revolution of 1911 until at least the death of Mao in 1976, China itself might be said to have lost the mandate of heaven. Frank Dikötter shows just how deeply the country descended into one cycle of hell. Not long after it was over Mao took into another – the Cultural Revolution. I can’t recommend this book highly enough.

About the Writer

Anastasia is a writer for BrooWaha. For more information, visit the writer's website.
Want to write articles too? Sign up & become a writer!

4 comments on The Heart of Horror

Log In To Vote   Score: 1
By Rebeca Lucret on July 11, 2011 at 08:57 am

I am often amazed at such human beings. Their story often fascinates me, but in a scary and unusal way. To me, it is one of life's unsolved mysteries. I could never understand how a person gets "there".

It's astounding how far they will go to get their beliefs and ideas imposed on others, that the atrocities unfold and there is very little anyone can do about it. It has always been my thinking that if one person can get a people to follow his ideas and create such mayhem, isn't there one person who could do the exact opposite and put a halt to such crimes? It simply amazes me. Perhaps, in this case I am an optimistic in thinking that there should have been someone like this for every mass crime that occurred and that is happenning as we speak. I mean where is the balance? Did it ever exist? Will it ever exist?

I shall take note of this book. I appreciate a book that gets you at the vivid and gory details. Your chosen excerpts sound like the book does just that.

Thank you!

 Report abuse

Log In To Vote   Score: 2
By Anastasia on July 11, 2011 at 07:05 pm

Julian, you are absolutely right. Maoism was the most virulent form of a disease that gripped humanity in the course of the last century, the disease of ideology, the belief, as I once headed an article, that utopia could be built on skulls. One can only hope it has run its dreadful course

 Report abuse

Log In To Vote   Score: 1
By Anastasia on July 11, 2011 at 07:07 pm

Rebecca, thank you. Monsters are always with us in one fashion or another but, like you, I don't fully understand how some get in a position of such absolute power, where their madness turns into state method.

 Report abuse

Log In To Vote   Score: 0
By Anastasia on July 12, 2011 at 04:31 am

Melody, yes, that's quite right: on the wretched calculus of inhumanity communist regimes killed far more people than the Nazis ever did.

 Report abuse

Add A Comment!

Click here to signup or login.

Rate This Article

Your vote matters to us